Thursday, June 19, 2008

Activism and the Analogy of War, Part 2

I have a friend who is a strong opponent of the US-Iraq war. This person often participates in protests against the war. I once asked him what the solution should be, or, in other words, what he hoped to gain from protesting. In short, I wanted to know his prescriptions for what the US should do.

His answer: the US should never have invaded in the first place.

Fair enough, but now that the US has invaded, what should it do now?

His answer: the US should never have invaded in the first place.

Okay, but if the US withdraws "precipitously" (to use a favorite word of Bushites), mightn't doing so cause the Iraqi people a lot of problems?

His answer: I'm not saying the US should withdraw right away. Now that it has invaded, it's got to find a way to ensure peace.

Then why protest? What do you hope to gain?

His answer: the US should never have invaded in the first place.

No comments: